Identify the 'right’ limit on selective coordination

In 2005, the National Electric Code was changed to require selective coordination of circuit protection for emergency circuits and legally-required standby systems. Its goal was to ensure that if one circuit overloaded or faulted, it would not cause a blackout or other circuits to lose power in places like hospitals and elevators, where losing power could be hazardous.


In 2005, the National Electric Code was changed to require selective coordination of circuit protection for emergency circuits and legally-required standby systems. Its goal was to ensure that if one circuit overloaded or faulted, it would not cause a blackout or other circuits to lose power in places like hospitals and elevators, where losing power could be hazardous.

Common sense says that a circuit breaker with a lower current rating than the upstream circuit protection device by a ratio of 2:1 will always open first. Actually, if plant managers and electricians fully understood how selective coordination works, they would see why this isn’t always the case, and why the standards were written. What’s more, they would see the value of upgrading to current-limiting devices to meet the selective coordination standards and reduce electrical hazards.

According to the code

The NEC defines selective coordination as “localization of an overcurrent condition to restrict outages to the circuit or equipment affected, accomplished by the choice of overcurrent protective devices and their ratings or settings.” At first the NEC selective coordination requirements covered only elevator feeders (Article 620.62) and healthcare facilities (517.26), but in 2005 the NEC authors added emergency systems (700.27) and legally-required standby systems (701.18). Emergency systems supply power to systems such as emergency lighting and fire pumps. Legally-required standby systems supply power to equipment that aids in firefighting, rescue and control of health hazards. Many state and local building codes require compliance with the NEC for selective coordination, at least for certain types of facilities.

The point of selective coordination is to isolate the faulted portion of the circuit while maintaining power to the rest of the electrical system. It’s not hard to see how this is handy %%MDASSML%% nobody wants a plant’s emergency exit signs to go dark when one load is faulted. Selectivity is accomplished using coordinated circuit protection.

Coordinating circuit protection

The data sheet for an overcurrent protective device will show a time-current curve that describes the time the device will take to clear a fault at a given value of fault current. Electrical system designers use these specifications to put the fastest-clearing devices closest to the load (Fig. 1).

Circuit breakers can be used in selectively coordinated electrical systems, but specifiers must overlay the time-current curves of all upstream (line side) and downstream (load side) breakers to ensure that the downstream circuit breaker will open under a short-circuit condition before the upstream circuit breaker operates. To ensure that a circuit-breaker-protected system is selectively coordinated, the time-current curves must not overlap at any possible fault current.

With fuses, selective coordination is achieved as long as specifiers maintain manufacturer-recommended ratios. For example, an upstream fuse rated 200 A and a downstream fuse rated 100 A provide a 2:1 ratio. Plant managers can ask their supplier for a fuse coordination table that lists the recommended ratios for fuses by model number, type and rating. When using a UL Class J fuse (30-600 A) line side, and a UL Class RK-1 fuse load side, the recommended ratio is 2:1. For a Class J fuse line side and a UL Class RK-5 fuse load side, an 8:1 ratio is recommended because an RK-5 fuse has a longer time delay at high fault currents.

Load comparisons

During moderate overload conditions, circuit breakers and fuses work just fine, operating selectively. However, during very high overcurrent conditions (such as a fault), circuit breakers do not always operate selectively. Because most circuit breakers have a range of trip times that overlap each other at high potential fault currents, system designers cannot be assured that the lower current rated circuit breaker will open before the higher rated circuit breaker begins to open (Fig. 2).

If fuses are used on the line side as well as on the load side, then a similar situation can occur if the ratings ratio is not sufficient. This points to the importance of understanding the electrical system and knowing what kind of circuit protection is in place at every piece of equipment.

Plant managers may be intimidated by the idea of a selective coordination study of their entire plant. Fortunately, there is an easier way to achieve guaranteed selective coordination: current limiting devices.

UL-Listed current-limiting fuses or current-limiting circuit breakers must open within the firstger than a typical current-limiting fuse or current-limiting circuit breaker.

A properly sized current-limiting fuse near the load will open before a circuit breaker located upstream. However, there are differences in the degree of current-limitation. For example, UL Class RK-1 fuses are more current-limiting than UL Class RK-5 fuses. And UL Class J, T and CC fuses are more current-limiting than Class RK-5 or Class RK-1 fuses.

Fuse limitations

Fuses are not without their drawbacks. In higher current ratings, fuses can be physically larger than molded case circuit breakers of equivalent rating. Generally, current-limiting fuses cannot be used line-side if there is a non-current-limiting circuit breaker load-side because the fuse would operate faster than the circuit breaker at high fault currents.

Using a fuse load-side and a circuit breaker line-side may not provide selectivity if there is a rare phenomenon called dynamic impedance. Under high faults, if the line side circuit breaker’s contacts begin to open momentarily before the arc is extinguished by the fuse, the decrease in current due to the air gap will slow down the response of the fuse so that the breaker may also open. Specifiers must compare the minimum possible response time of the circuit breaker and maximum possible clearing time of the fuse to determine if dynamic impedance is a factor.

Current-limiting benefits

Current-limiting overcurrent protective devices have other advantages for the plant, starting with safety. Current-limiting devices dramatically reduce the destructive energy of a short circuit or arc flash. The instantaneous peak current during the first half cycle after a fault can reach as high as 2.3 times the available RMS bolted-fault-current available at the equipment. For example, if current-limiting overcurrent protective devices are not used and the available fault current at an industrial control panel is 100,000 A, the maximum possible instantaneous peak current reached could be as high as 233,000 A. If a 200-A rated current-limiting fuse were used, the maximum instantaneous peak let-through current during the first cycle would be only 20,000 A. If a 30-A rated current-limiting fuse were used, the instantaneous peak let-through current would be only 6,000 A.

In addition to limiting the instantaneous peak let-through current, current-limiting devices reduce arc flash incident energy. It is estimated that there are 10 arc flash incidents everyday in the United States, and the resulting burns are sometimes fatal. Current-limiting fuses and breakers shorten the duration of an arc flash event. A

Also, current-limiting fuses can increase the Short Circuit Current Rating of industrial control panels, which according to the 2005 edition of NEC, Article 409, must be clearly marked on the panels. Most states and authorities having jurisdiction have adopted the 2005 edition of the NEC as their standard for safe electrical installations.

The motivation for selective coordination %%MDASSML%% from the NEC perspective %%MDASSML%% is safety, by preserving power to critical systems. However, selective coordination in a plant can also reduce unplanned work stoppages and help speed troubleshooting. Although not required by NEC for all systems, selective coordination is best practice, and it can be easily accomplished by replacing traditional fuses and circuit breakers with current limiting fuses.

Author Information
Kenneth Cybart is a senior technical sales engineer at Littelfuse, Des Plaines, IL.

Top Plant
The Top Plant program honors outstanding manufacturing facilities in North America.
Product of the Year
The Product of the Year program recognizes products newly released in the manufacturing industries.
System Integrator of the Year
Each year, a panel of Control Engineering and Plant Engineering editors and industry expert judges select the System Integrator of the Year Award winners in three categories.
October 2018
Tools vs. sensors, functional safety, compressor rental, an operational network of maintenance and safety
September 2018
2018 Engineering Leaders under 40, Women in Engineering, Six ways to reduce waste in manufacturing, and Four robot implementation challenges.
GAMS preview, 2018 Mid-Year Report, EAM and Safety
October 2018
2018 Product of the Year; Subsurface data methodologies; Digital twins; Well lifecycle data
August 2018
SCADA standardization, capital expenditures, data-driven drilling and execution
June 2018
Machine learning, produced water benefits, programming cavity pumps
Spring 2018
Burners for heat-treating furnaces, CHP, dryers, gas humidification, and more
October 2018
Complex upgrades for system integrators; Process control safety and compliance
September 2018
Effective process analytics; Four reasons why LTE networks are not IIoT ready

Annual Salary Survey

After two years of economic concerns, manufacturing leaders once again have homed in on the single biggest issue facing their operations:

It's the workers—or more specifically, the lack of workers.

The 2017 Plant Engineering Salary Survey looks at not just what plant managers make, but what they think. As they look across their plants today, plant managers say they don’t have the operational depth to take on the new technologies and new challenges of global manufacturing.

Read more: 2017 Salary Survey

The Maintenance and Reliability Coach's blog
Maintenance and reliability tips and best practices from the maintenance and reliability coaches at Allied Reliability Group.
One Voice for Manufacturing
The One Voice for Manufacturing blog reports on federal public policy issues impacting the manufacturing sector. One Voice is a joint effort by the National Tooling and Machining...
The Maintenance and Reliability Professionals Blog
The Society for Maintenance and Reliability Professionals an organization devoted...
Machine Safety
Join this ongoing discussion of machine guarding topics, including solutions assessments, regulatory compliance, gap analysis...
Research Analyst Blog
IMS Research, recently acquired by IHS Inc., is a leading independent supplier of market research and consultancy to the global electronics industry.
Marshall on Maintenance
Maintenance is not optional in manufacturing. It’s a profit center, driving productivity and uptime while reducing overall repair costs.
Lachance on CMMS
The Lachance on CMMS blog is about current maintenance topics. Blogger Paul Lachance is president and chief technology officer for Smartware Group.
Material Handling
This digital report explains how everything from conveyors and robots to automatic picking systems and digital orders have evolved to keep pace with the speed of change in the supply chain.
Electrical Safety Update
This digital report explains how plant engineers need to take greater care when it comes to electrical safety incidents on the plant floor.
IIoT: Machines, Equipment, & Asset Management
Articles in this digital report highlight technologies that enable Industrial Internet of Things, IIoT-related products and strategies.
Randy Steele
Maintenance Manager; California Oils Corp.
Matthew J. Woo, PE, RCDD, LEED AP BD+C
Associate, Electrical Engineering; Wood Harbinger
Randy Oliver
Control Systems Engineer; Robert Bosch Corp.
Data Centers: Impacts of Climate and Cooling Technology
This course focuses on climate analysis, appropriateness of cooling system selection, and combining cooling systems.
Safety First: Arc Flash 101
This course will help identify and reveal electrical hazards and identify the solutions to implementing and maintaining a safe work environment.
Critical Power: Hospital Electrical Systems
This course explains how maintaining power and communication systems through emergency power-generation systems is critical.
Design of Safe and Reliable Hydraulic Systems for Subsea Applications
This eGuide explains how the operation of hydraulic systems for subsea applications requires the user to consider additional aspects because of the unique conditions that apply to the setting
click me