Maintenance Strategy

Business process improvement project benefits valve manufacturer

A valve manufacturing company went through a business process improvement project that involved enterprise resource planning (ERP) evaluation and selection engagement.
By Ultra Consultants November 12, 2018
Courtesy: Bob Vavra, CFE Media

A manufacturing company went through a business process improvement project that involved enterprise resource planning (ERP) evaluation and selection engagement.

The U.S.-based valve manufacturer designs and manufactures fluid control valves and components for original equipment manufacturers (OEMs) in aerospace, defense, nuclear and power, land and sea and other key vertical markets. The company operates out of a state-of-the-art production and test facility.

Business process improvement project in action

The business process improvement project got underway by taking the time to document the company’s processes through current state mapping.

When the business process analysis was conducted, several parts of the current business were evaluated including production and operations. Key questions were asked such as if the current business processes added value to the business if there was a waste in any of the processes, and if there were redundancies in the processes and data versus more streamlined, automated processes.

According to operational leaders at the company, an “as is” process that was identified as particularly problematic was the daily production meetings and the creation, use and tracking of the dispatch list.

The firm’s dispatch list sets the production prioritization schedule for each work center. It lists orders in the exact sequence they should be produced, based on due date or other considerations.

In previous years, it was a manual and error-prone process to assemble the detailed listing of all the orders to be produced based on priority.

Because of the manual processing and inefficient handling of the daily dispatch list, the production team was forced to sit through more than 20 hours per week of meetings and manual review. More than eight people gathered each morning for the daily production meeting for over an hour and met again at the end of the day to look at the dispatch list and prioritize the items.

Accuracy was also a concern. Data in the dispatch list did not reflect current production metrics and was constantly being reviewed and modified by supervisors from each work center, operations director, planners, product line leads, schedulers, and other key production personnel.

“This dispatch list is crucial as it basically translates our production plan into action. The company thinks of this list as the “heartbeat of production. Since the list is required to assign jobs to each work center, it was a huge issue that we didn’t trust the data on the dispatch list,” noted the operations manager.

The twice-per-day meetings were spent looking at whiteboards of hand-generated production lists, which were outdated and didn’t accurately reflect real-time production. In fact, the data would be out of date by the time the meeting ended, since parts were constantly moving through work centers.

Business process mapping

The business process improvement project looked to uncover the wasted effort and inaccuracies with the dispatch list during “current state” mapping.

The mapping exercise revealed the root cause of the problem as lack of data standards within the legacy systems. Production data standards within the existing solution and automate production data tracking were added. The improvements were put into place without adding any additional technology.

Now, the reports are no longer hand-generated. Instead, they are automatically pulled as needed with real-time data. The company cut the need for the twice-daily meetings and has confidence they can accurately track production information the team must know before they start on work orders.

The business process mapping phase of the business process improvement project was performed to uncover any problems or issues with the processes well before the process of ERP implementation began. Production reports are now automatically pulled as needed with real-time data. The company cut the need for 20 hours of meetings each week.

Lessons learned

The valve manufacturer experienced several “lessons learned” from this business process improvement project. Three lessons in particular stood out.

  • Improved processes before technology: Primarily, the company sees the value of putting the focus on business process improvement and not solely technology.
  • Reduction in clerical effort, meetings and manual handling: The improved processes cut clerical effort and reduced the time spent in meetings ended up cutting out nearly 20 hours of meetings once needed a week.
  • Improved production scheduling accuracy: By establishing data standards and reducing duplicate data entry and manual efforts, the company sees improvements in accuracy.

While the company is still moving through ERP implementation, this business process improvement project is an example of benefiting from improving processes before adding new information systems.

Finally, the manufacturer sees the benefit in having the business improvement project led with change management methods, so the users could understand why the new processes were important and the ultimate value to the business.

Ultra Consultants, a CFE Media content partner, is a leading independent research and enterprise solutions consulting firm serving the manufacturing and distribution industries throughout North America. Ultra delivers enterprise technology expertise and process management to drive business performance improvement for their clients. This article originally appeared on Ultra Consultants’ blog.


Ultra Consultants
Author Bio: Ultra Consultants, a CFE Media content partner, is a leading independent research and enterprise solutions consulting firm serving the manufacturing and distribution industries throughout North America. Ultra delivers enterprise technology expertise and process management to drive business performance improvement for their clients.